Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier has delivered another decision that will delight Second Amendment advocates and infuriate the gun control lobby. In a written opinion, the AG says that his office will not defend any convictions under the state's 2018 ban on bump stocks.
The ban was included in the package of gun control laws adopted after the 2018 murders at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida. Uthmeier has also declined to defend the ban on gun sales to adults under the age of 21 that was another component in the package, but the Supreme Court denied cert to the NRA's lawsuit against the ban, keeping an Eleventh Circuit decision that upheld the prohibition in place.
Uthmeier has also declined to defend the state's three-day waiting period on firearms, though in that case a federal judge has rejected a jointly requested judgment from both the plaintiffs and the AG in a lawsuit challenging the waiting period that would have prevented enforcement of the waiting period once a background check was completed.
Instead, U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday decided last month that he wanted adversarial briefing before deciding the constitutional question, and invited Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, the Florida legislature, and the legal arms of Brady and Giffords to submit briefs of their own about waiting periods.
There's no active litigation taking on Florida's bump stock ban, at least that I've been able to find, so it's unclear what prompted Uthmeier's move to declare bump stocks protected by the Second Amendment.
People are being arrested and prosecuted under a 2018 law that banned “bump stocks.” As currently written, the overly broad law appears to restrict the use of trigger enhancements used by firearms owners for lawful purposes, subjecting them to five years in prison. Today, my office issued a legal opinion recognizing the law as unconstitutional under the Second Amendment, and this office will not defend a conviction under the statute going forward.
— Attorney General James Uthmeier (@AGJamesUthmeier) November 13, 2026
In Uthmeier's opinion, whether bump stocks are labeled components of a firearm or accessories, they still fall within the "arms" protected by the Second Amendment. Uthmeier says bump stocks are widely used for lawful purposes, and do not make semi-automatic firearms more dangerous than they already are.
Because Florida's bump stock ban implicates the plain text of the Second Amendment, Uthmeier says it's up to the state to prove that its ban fits within the historic tradition of firearms regulation, and that he's simply found no evidence to suggest a tradition of banning components that help speed up the rate of fire.
The history of firearms actually shows the exact opposite. From the beginning, inventors and tinkerers have tried to improve the rate of fire, and it's not until we get into the 20th century that we see widespread attempts to ban certain firearms because they fire too quickly.
Still, Uthmeier says the government could potentially regulate components that truly do turn semi-automatic firearms into full auto machine guns. He just contends that bump stocks don't do that. One shot is fired for every pull of the trigger, even if a bump stock allows the trigger to be pulled more quickly than it would be without assistance.
Uthmeier didn't say how many prosecutions of Florida's bump stock ban have taken place, and I'd be curious to see those numbers. Whatever they are, though, my guess is that we won't be seeing many more. Some of Florida's liberal enclaves might still try to enforce the ban, but I suspect that most state's attorneys will follow the attorney general's lead here.