I don't know any gun owners who carry a firearm because they're just itching for the chance to defend themselves from an armed robber or violent criminal. But when trouble comes looking for you, having a gun can mean the difference between becoming another innocent victim and making it home alive.

Two recent incidents in Michigan and Missouri offer very different examples of that reality. In Detroit, an attempted carjacking ended with one suspect dead after the intended victim fought back with a gun. Meanwhile, prosecutors in Missouri have announced they won't charge an armed driver who fatally shot another motorist during a road-rage confrontation.

The circumstances were different, but both cases serve as reminders that violent encounters don't come with advance warning, and you can't depend on the police to be around when someone decides you'd make a pretty good victim.

Last Friday night, Detroit police responded to a report of an attempted carjacking. Thankfully, one of the two would-be victims had a gun of his own.

According to one of the victims, he and another person were in a Hyundai Elantra when two suspects in their 20s approached and announced a robbery. The suspects forced both victims out of the car and onto their knees.

The victim said one of the suspects then told the other to shoot them. That’s when one of the victims pulled out his gun and shot both suspects.

One suspect was pronounced deceased at the scene, while the other was hospitalized. I haven't seen any follow-up reporting that identifies either suspect or whether they were known to their intended victims, but from the initial reports this sounds like a clear-cut case of self-defense. When you're told to get on your knees and you hear a command to shoot you, I think it's fair to say you've got a reason to believe that your life is in danger. 

The defensive gun use in St. Louis is a little messier of a situation, but prosecutors say they won't be filing any charges because "the legal elements of self-defense were insurmountable." 

59-year-old Vance Townes was shot and killed around 11 PM on the night of September 22, after what police described as a road rage incident. 

Townes became frustrated with how slowly another man in a Honda was driving in front of him. In response, police said Townes passed the other driver, honking and yelling at him before both drivers pulled into the parking lot.

According to police, both men pulled out guns, but only the Honda driver fired. The driver fired five shots from inside his car, striking Townes. He was pronounced dead at the scene.

The Honda driver had a woman and two children in his car at the time of the shooting, police said. The man and his family had been driving around trying to get the children to fall asleep and were driving slowly because they believed a police officer was behind them. Runge said the driver who fired the fatal shots does not have a criminal history.

Fox 2 in St. Louis reported some additional details after prosecutors announced their decision not to file charges, and I have to say I'm actually a little surprised that they're not pursuing a case against the Honda driver.

Surveillance video obtained by FOX 2 captured the sequence of events preceding the fatal shooting in a nearby parking lot. The video showed the driver waiting at a green light to allow oncoming traffic to pass before driving the wrong way a short distance into the lot where Townes had stopped to use an ATM. Townes subsequently walked toward the parked vehicle, reportedly holding a handgun by his side, at which point the driver sitting inside the vehicle opened fire and shot him to death.

Why follow Townes into the parking lot in the first place? If he was concerned about the other man's behavior, wouldn't it have made more sense to keep driving, especially with two children in the car? Instead, he apparently was so eager to respond to the guy who had yelled at him that he drove the wrong way into the lot where Townes had stopped to use an ATM. 

I don't know why the Honda driver made that particular decision, but apparently prosecutors concluded that whatever mistakes the driver may have made, they didn't negate his right to defend himself when Townes approached his vehicle with a gun.

Trial attorney Jay Kanzler provided context regarding the lack of charges, explaining that a driver seated inside a vehicle who is approached by an armed individual maintains a clear legal right to shoot under state law.

“I do believe that a prosecutor has an obligation to not bring that case,” Kanzler said regarding the prosecutor’s decision.

As far as we know, Townes had no reason to believe that the Honda driver was armed, so it sounds like in drawing his gun and walking towards the Honda he became the aggressor, and the driver had a reasonable belief that his life and the lives of others in his car were in danger. 

In Detroit, the threat appears to have been unmistakable. In Missouri, the circumstances were much more nuanced, but prosecutors ultimately determined that they couldn't overcome the evidence supporting self-defense.

I think that's probably the right call, but it's still sad that shots were fired when both men had the opportunity to deescalate the situation. The frustrated dad just trying to get his kids to sleep could have kept on driving instead of pulling into the parking lot after Townes, and Townes could have returned to his car and driven away instead of pulling a gun and striding over to the Honda to confront the driver. 

Even though I don't think the Missouri driver should have followed Townes into that parking lot, he still possessed the right to protect himself and his family from an imminent deadly threat. You can make a bad decision and still have every right to defend yourself.