75-Year-Old Wisconsin Man Fatally Shoots Suspect Who Tried to Force His Way Inside

75-Year-Old Wisconsin Man Fatally Shoots Suspect Who Tried to Force His Way Inside
<a href="https://pixabay.com/users/paulsbarlow7">paulsbarlow7</a> / Pixabay

A 75-year-old Wisconsin man is alive today thanks in part to his decision to keep a handgun handy for self-defense. The same can't be said for the stranger who allegedly tried to force his way into the man's home early Sunday morning.

The deadly encounter in Oneida County is a reminder that even a quiet neighborhood can become a dangerous place in a matter of moments.

According to authorities, 35-year-old James Roath showed up outside an elderly woman's home around 1 AM on November 15. In fact, according to the resident, Roath was actually able to make his way inside the home before she finally managed to get him outside and locked the door behind him. 

Roath allegedly pounded on her door and kicked it before wandering away. When the woman called police, she told them that the stranger appeared to be intoxicated, which might explain why Roath then allegedly went to a neighboring home and began pounding on the side of the house, and then the front door. 

The homeowner, 75-year-old Marshall Robinson, armed himself with a handgun, opened the door and tried to ask Roth who he was. Roath grabbed Robinson’s glasses and tried to push his way inside. Robinson then raised the handgun and fired, striking Roath.

Deputies and medical personnel attempted lifesaving measures, but Roath was pronounced dead at the scene.

I guess we'll never know what Roath's intentions were, but it's not like he recognized he was at the wrong home and apologized before stumbling off into the darkness. The first homeowner would likely have been justified in using deadly force against the stranger who entered her home uninvited, but there's an even stronger case that Robinson acted in self-defense after Roath grabbed the man's glasses and tried to force his way inside the home. 

Wisconsin's self-defense statutes state, in part, that there's a presumption deadly force is reasonably necessary when:

In this case, Roath was attempting to unlawfully and forcibly enter Robinson's dwelling, so the presumption that deadly force was reasonably necessary should apply. Even if Roath had no real intention to harm Robinson, there was no way for the 75-year-old man to know that. All he knew was that a stranger had been pounding on the side of his home and at his front door at 1 AM, and when he cracked the door to see what was going on the stranger grabbed at his glasses and tried to shove his way inside. 

If I were in Robinson's shoes (or slippers), I wouldn't assume that this stranger was there to drop off an Amazon package or deliver a late-night snack. My assumption would be that this guy meant to do me harm, and I think it's reasonable for Robinson to have come to that same conclusion. 

If there are any lessons to be learned here, one is that you shouldn't drink to the point where you can't even tell the difference between your home and a stranger's residence. Of course, that's assuming that Roath really didn't have any ill intent towards either of the homeowners he accosted. 

The other lesson is that you don't have to be looking for trouble to find yourself in a situation where your life is in danger. Robinson was minding his own business in the middle of the night when a stranger started pounding on his house and then tried to force his way inside. At 75, Robinson might not have stood much of a chance in a physical confrontation with a man less than half his age, and he shouldn't have to take his chances in a fistfight with a stranger who has no business being in his home. Robinson had every reason to be afraid of what might happen if Roath made it through that doorway, and every right to protect himself from that possibility.