Given the Democrat majorities in the Illinois statehouse, it feels like the odds of a truly pro-Second Amendment bill passing either chamber are about as good as you or I winning the Mega Millions lottery. 

And it's hard to classify House Bill 3739 as a bill that offers nothing but improvements for gun owners. One aspect of the bill deals with reinstating Firearm Owner ID cards after they've been revoked or suspended because of a clear and present danger determination, and it would require individuals to get at least two mental health evaluation visits on separate days. Current law requires a mental health evaluation for certain individuals seeking to regain their FOID cards, so mandating two evaluations could easily add to the expense and wait time for reinstating the card that's necessary to simply possess a firearm at home in the state. 

The better part of the bill would allow for non-residents to obtain an Illinois license to carry. That language might be a direct result of a lawsuit filed earlier this year called Henrichs v. Kelly. 

Gun Owners of America and a Tennessee couple filed suit in federal court alleging that Illinois' refusal to allow non-residents to apply for a carry license unless the permitting process in their home state is "substantially similar" to its own violates the Second Amendment. At the moment, that means residents of just six other states can apply for an Illinois carry license, but if non-residents can generally apply for an Illinois license then Attorney General Kwame Raoul can argue that the Henrichs and other gun owners have the ability to obtain an Illinois carry permit if they want to bear arms while visiting the state. 

The process for getting one of those permits still wouldn't be all that easy, though. In addition to the 16 hours of training that Illinois requires, applicants have to submit "documentation and information required by the Illinois State Police to obtain a Firearms Owner Identification Card, including an affidavit that the non-resident meets the mental health standards to obtain a firearm under Illinois law."

And there's another catch: Illinois charges non-residents $300 for a concealed carry license, compared to $150 for residents. That's a pretty steep price to pay for exercising a constitutional right, and the disparity raises some interesting Equal Protection questions under the Fourteenth Amendment. Why should someone who lives in Indiana or Wisconsin have to pay twice as much as an Illinois resident for permission to exercise the same right?

Still, opening up the application process to residents of every other state and territory would be a genuine improvement over the current system, which leaves most Americans with no way to legally carry a concealed firearm in Illinois, regardless of how much training they've received or how long they've held a license in their home state.

I suspect that's one reason why the Illinois State Rifle Association is supporting HB 3739 despite the additional requirements for some FOID reinstatements. The bill isn't perfect, but it would eliminate an arbitrary barrier that's kept millions of otherwise eligible gun owners from even applying for an Illinois carry license.

Whether that's enough to satisfy the plaintiffs in Henrichs v. Kelly remains to be seen. Being allowed to apply for a permit isn't the same thing as having your right to bear arms respected, especially when exercising that right requires hundreds of dollars in fees and 16 hours of state-approved training.

I'd much rather see Illinois simply recognize carry licenses issued by other states. Better yet, allow peaceable adults to carry without having to beg the government for permission in the first place.

But given the political makeup of the Illinois legislature, neither of those developments is a realistic possibility. HB 3739 may be a modest step forward, but for millions of gun owners who currently have no legal path to carry in Illinois, a small step is better than standing still.