We've all heard the objections by gun control advocates to the idea of armed school staff: accidental shootings, students getting their hands on unsecured guns, and police officers mistaking armed teachers for attackers.
Despite those concerns, there are hundreds of school districts around the country with thousands of armed staffers in place. And as it turns out, a new study from the Crime Prevention Research Center found no deaths or injuries from a shooting attack during or near classroom hours were reported between 2000 and 2025 at schools that allow authorized teachers and other non-uniformed staff to carry firearms.
And despite all the warnings about the dangers posed by armed educators, the study found no instances of a teacher accidentally shooting a student, a student using a teacher's gun to harm someone, or police mistakenly shooting an armed teacher.
Over that same 26-year period, there were 39 attacks that produced casualties other than to the attacker at the public schools (currently totaling 44,000) that use law enforcement or other uniformed armed guards for protection. In addition, officers accidentally discharged their firearms 20 times, with additional incidents involving struggles or private guards. In three cases, officers shot someone other than the intended target or a bystander they misidentified, all at schools where state law banned teachers and permit holders from carrying.
The greatest number of incidents, by far, occurred at schools with neither officers nor armed teachers: 551 between 2000-2025. Armed officers protect about 44.5% of schools, while 42.2% have neither officers nor armed teachers. Adjusting for these shares, schools without either form of armed protection experienced attacks involving casualties at 14.9 times the rate of schools with armed officers.
As Dr. John Lott writes at RealClearInvestigations, this suggests that the presence of non-uniformed armed staff is having a deterrent effect on potential school shooters.
The presence of nonuniformed gun holders may deter attacks because the would-be perpetrator does not know who might offer lethal resistance. On May 25, 2021, for example, a teacher at Lincoln Elementary School in Ogden confronted a 41-year-old man who tried to kidnap an 11-year-old girl on the school playground. The girl broke free and ran into the school. The man chased her and tried to force his way inside. The teacher, who held a concealed carry permit, drew his firearm and held the man at gunpoint until police arrived.
The safety of schools with armed teachers and other nonuniformed adults undermines many of the arguments for gun-free zones. Legislative debates over allowing teachers to carry are filled with concerns about what might go wrong. “Teachers and coaches have bad days too. Principals have bad days as well,” Mississippi state Rep. David Myers (D-McComb) said when he warned that they could get angry or lose control and shoot someone.
Of course teachers and principals have bad days, but we don't see a lot of stories about unarmed teachers or school administrators beating students for no reason, using their cars to run down students in parking lots, or stabbing kids with pencils. Why, then, would we think that a school employee who's been vetted and trained is suddenly going to go postal if they're carrying a gun?
The answer, at least based on the evidence Lott has compiled, is that we shouldn't.
After 26 years of experience with armed educators, the parade of horribles predicted by gun control advocates simply hasn't materialized in the schools examined by the Crime Prevention Research Center.
Nobody is suggesting that every teacher should be required to carry a gun, or that arming staff should replace school resource officers, improved security measures, or other efforts to keep students safe. We're talking about giving willing and qualified adults another option to protect themselves and the children entrusted to their care. Ideally, schools would have both armed staff and resource officers, along with hardened security like remote-locking doors and secured entrances.
For years, opponents of armed school staff have questioned what could go wrong if teachers were allowed to carry. Lott's research raises a much more important question: How many tragedies might be prevented if more schools gave responsible staffers the ability to fight back when someone walks onto campus with murderous intent?