As we reported earlier today, the town of Summit, New Jersey is considering a ban on gun stores, which could prove to be constitutionally problematic. The Third Circuit, which has jurisdiction over New Jersey, has previously held that a "categorical exception for rules 'prohibiting the commercial sale of firearms' would be 'untenable in light of Heller," and now the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals has gone even further in a case called U.S. v. Deare.

In a decision handed down on Thursday, a three-judge panel concluded that the plain text of the Second Amendment protects the buying and selling of firearms, not just the right to keep and bear them. They reversed a lower court decision denying Jeremiah Deare’s motion to dismiss the DOJ's indictment for conspiracy to engage in the business of dealing firearms without a federal firearms license and making false statements with respect to records of licensed firearms dealers, and remanded the case back to the district court for a do-over. 

That decision doesn't automatically get Mr. Deare off the hook, but it's bad news for states in the Fifth Circuit's jurisdiction that might impose various restrictions on the purchase and sale of firearms in the future. 

Judge Catharina Jacoba Hendrika Dubbelday Hayne dissented from the two judges in the majority, writing that while she doesn't think the Second Amendment covers the sellers of firearms since the sale of guns isn't mentioned in the text:

... even assuming arguendo the sellers are covered, I see nothing in this case that shows that the rules for the sellers in this context are inappropriate and, therefore, unconstitutional. Also, to me, since Deare did not properly challenge the relevant rules to show that they are abusive, I do not see a need to remand on that.

Judge James Ho and Judge Andrew Oldham both wrote concurring opinions explaining why they disagree with Hayne, with Ho noting that "it seems obvious that constitutional rights are meaningless if the Government can simply prohibit the means by which citizens are able to exercise those rights."

[A]s the dissent puts it simply, “the Second Amendment . . . doesn’t mention sellers,” so “I do not think that the sellers of guns are covered.” By that logic, the First Amendment doesn’t mention sellers, so presumably booksellers aren’t covered by the First Amendment, either. But that can’t be right.

No, it can't. 

Oldham, meanwhile, told the district court that on remand, it should ignore the Fifth Circuit's previous decision in Peterson, in which a three-judge panel declared that Bruen imposes a “presumption of constitutionality for shall-issue licensing regimes," and that the National Firearms Act operates as a shall-issue licensing system.

This is wrong coming and going and coming back again. Start with Bruen’s ninth footnote. It says only that “nothing in our analysis should be interpreted to suggest the unconstitutionality of the 43 States’ ‘shall-issue ’licensing regimes.” Neither the word “presumption” nor any variant of it appears anywhere in this footnote. And nothing in this footnote creates a presumption of any kind. 

Moreover, Peterson wrenches footnote nine from context. Bruen concerned a so-called “may-issue regime” for concealed-carry permits. In a “may-issue” jurisdiction like New York, “authorities have discretion to deny concealed-carry licenses even when the applicant satisfies the statutory criteria, usually because the applicant has not demonstrated cause or suitability for the relevant license.” The Supreme Court held such may-issue laws violate the Second Amendment. But it said nothing about the constitutionality of shall-issue laws. Footnote nine merely “clarified that shall-issue licensing regimes are not necessarily unconstitutional just because may-issue regimes are.”

... Finally, even reading Peterson for all that it’s worth, it should not be extended to this case. Assume for the sake of discussion that the NFA’s registration regime is “presumptively constitutional” as Peterson says. That tells us nothing about § 922(a) and the Gun Control Act’s limitations on firearm sales. Nothing in § 922(a) requires registration of anything. And nothing in § 922(a) says anything about ATF databases. Had we applied Peterson as the Government urged, we would have taken a footnote about carry licenses, extended it to firearm registration, and then extended it again to firearm sales. We’d have moved from football to baseball to ballroom dance.

I love it when judges get a little snarky, especially when it's in support of our Second Amendment rights. 

Beneath Oldham's colorful criticism is a serious point: the Supreme Court's narrow remarks about shall-issue carry permits shouldn't be transformed into a blanket endorsement of every licensing scheme a government can dream up. And if the Second Amendment protects the right to acquire firearms, then the government shouldn't be able to regulate that right out of existence by targeting the people who sell them.