Attorney Alan Beck, who litigated Wolford v. Lopez, took a look at Connecticut’s reply brief in the combined Viramontes and Grant cases. Beck says the state’s evidence is factually flawed.

Beck analyzed the Constitution State’s reply brief filed with the U.S. Supreme Court and found several holes in its theories. Beck wrote about several examples from the 14th through the 19th Century over at The Reload.

“In the brief, Connecticut justifies its ban by citing historical English laws from as far back as the 14th Century that it argues prohibited possession of several kinds of weapons,” Beck wrote. “Given what it held in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen, the Supreme Court is unlikely to rely on English laws many decades or even centuries removed from the Founding when deciding the case.”

In his piece, Beck contends that the laws Connecticut is relying on are not what they claim, “even taken at face value.” Alleged prohibitions from the 1300s on lancegays, restrictions on crossbows and handguns, and a law that reportedly banned all firearm possession were used as analogous regulations. In each instance, Beck notes that Connecticut blindly cited these laws or regulations and did so without adding the proper context.

While being interviewed by The Reload founder, Stephen Gutowski, Beck said that he turned to academics when looking into the matter in an unrelated case he litigated in California.

“I had already dealt with this argument in a litigation I'm doing against California, which is challenging the Billy club ban or the former Billy club ban,” Beck told Gutowski. “I'd looked at this lancegay prohibition that was referenced, and you know what I did was I stopped looking what the lawyers were saying and what even the legal academics, and I decided to go look up what actual historians that are just simply medieval historians that don't have anything to do with this, and you know, there's a lot of suggestion that lancegays were freely legal to own.”

The lancegay ban referred to a medieval-era weapon that’s “a type of spear or lance, but that it was probably considerably lighter than a full-length war lance.” Connecticut contends that the ban on lancegay possession is analogous with its AR-15 ban. However, Beck points out a detail the defense team failed to cite.

“But the 1383 law only banned possessing a lancegay while riding,” Beck wrote. “It prohibited carrying lancegays unless one had a special license from the King. Richard II later ‘affirmed the validity of his 1383 legislation’ in 1396 with the second law Connecticut relies on and ‘ordained and assented that no man shall ride armed within the realm, against the form of the Statute of Northampton thereupon made, nor with launcegays.’”

Beyond the rhetorical misstep in Connecticut’s brief, Beck found further evidence that not only was the ban not really a ban, lancegays were actually popular and widely owned. One piece of historical evidence Beck provided referenced a list of items being bequeathed via a will. Wills of that era were recorded with a court. He argued that there’s no way the lancegay was banned if the court allowed one to be willed from one person to another.

The evidence that Beck brought forward in the instance of the lancegays, as well as how he deconstructed several other alleged analogues will be useful in how the case gets litigated on December 2 at the Supreme Court. Beck’s full analysis of how Connecticut perverted and went on a selective fact-finding mission is worth a full read. The Reload is a member-funded publication, however Beck’s article is not paywalled. “Analysis: Connecticut’s AR-15 Ban Defense Relies on Misreading Medieval English History,” by Alan Beck can be read HERE.