The term "mentally defective" isn't exactly politically correct these days, but it does describe a certain segment of society pretty well. People who suffer from fairly severe cognitive issues as well as profound mental illnesses could be considered "mentally defective" and, in the case of the law, there's a reason most people would prefer someone like this not to have a gun.

But the issue with the term is that it's poorly defined. All federal law says is that those "adjudicated as mentally defective" cannot own a firearm.

And, unsurprisingly, this is being challenged.

Unfortunately, it seems the Sixth Circuit doesn't see an issue with the prohibition. We missed this when it happened, but we need to talk about it.

On October 29, 2026, a panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit rejected a facial challenge to the constitutionality of 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(4), which prohibits anyone “who has been adjudicated as a mental defective or who has been committed to a mental institution” from possessing firearms. Judge Eric Murphy (a 2019 Trump appointee) authored the opinion, joined by Judges Gibbons and Hermandorfer.

By way of background, in January 2023, a Missouri court ordered that Lakovich be detained in a mental health facility for 21 days because his “mental illness” created “a likelihood of serious harm to himself or to others.” The court also deemed him to be “incompetent” under Missouri's concealed-carry laws and banned him from possessing firearms. Laykovich could have petitioned the state for removal of the ban, upon demonstrating that he no longer posed a threat to public safety, but he never filed such a petition. Rather, in January 2024, Laykovich was pulled over for erratic driving near Fort Knox, Kentucky. At the time of the stop, Laykovich was wearing body armor and a body cam; upon a search of the vehicle, officers “uncovered eight firearms (including two rifles), a large amount of ammunition, knives, a gasoline can, marijuana, and a pill that contained fentanyl.” He stated that he was on his way to Fort Knox to discuss something related to a "clearance" dispute. He was then arrested. Upon investigation, law enforcement discovered his 2023 institutionalization, and he was charged under 922(g)(4).

In other words, this doesn't strike me as someone who is particularly well even now.

There's no official mention of what the mental hospital admission was about, which could matter or it might not matter at all.

Still, Lakovich didn't petition to have the ban lifted, which may be because he was unaware of the ban or because he couldn't meet the standards. Regardless, he pushed his luck and got jammed up for it.

Regulating possession by the mentally ill raises interesting doctrinal questions—notably that our understanding of mental illness has evolved significantly since 1791 and 1868, as has the law's treatment of persons with mental illness. Furthermore, as the court noted, “Mental illness is a broad concept that could cover everything from a severe case of schizophrenia to a mild case of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder,” yet 922(g)(4) provides no guidance as to what types of mental illnesses may serve as the basis for disarmament. However, because Laykovich challenged his conviction on facial grounds, and because he failed to show that there were no circumstances in which the law could be constitutionally applied, his challenge failed and the court did not need to engage with the nuances of those questions.

Applying Bruen, the court first engaged with the “plain text” inquiry, holding that Laykovich’s “conduct falls within the ‘plain text’ of the Second Amendment” because he “remained part of the ‘people’ protected by the Second Amendment even after he was ‘adjudicated as a mental defective.’” Indeed, the Government conceded the point.

But at step two, the court determined that there were sufficient relevantly similar historical analogues to uphold § 922(g)(4). Reminder that at step two, the government must offer historical analogues that burden the right in sufficiently similar ways to their modern counterpart. Put differently, they must share a “how and why.”

The court argued that "society has long recognized that individuals suffering from severe mental illness might pose dangers to themselves and to others. And society has long responded to these dangers by restricting the liberty of these individuals until their mental health has improved." 

Now, I've personally got mixed feelings about this.

The Second Amendment doesn't say that only certain people's right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed, but all of "the people's."

That said, this isn't exactly a new idea. We've long confined people who were a danger to themselves or the general public. Asylums were a thing, and while they might not be considered barbaric, the reality is that there are some people who are just too damaged to be trusted with anything more than a kitchen utensil, and not even some of those, really.

As such, I'm going to do something strange for me and not opine on this one too strongly. 

What I will say is that this case, should it continue along the judicial pathway, could have deeper ramifications. Should the Supreme Court hear this case and rule on it, it's entirely possible that they could reach beyond the specifics of this case and define matters in such a way that it stamps out red flag laws...or they could do the opposite and reinforce them through their ruling.

Most likely, this case doesn't go much of anywhere. Laykovich isn't exactly the best rallying point for gun rights here, especially since I suspect there weren't any real "clearance issues" to be resolved beyond him being a complete and utter loon. I don't know that for certain, though, just my suspicion considering all of the information included.

The presence of hard drugs like fentanyl just makes it more likely that the man has a few thousand screws loose and thus really should be adjudicated as mentally defective.

But if we're going to continue with that, we need hard and fast determinations of what actually constitutes that adjudication; something beyond "he was hospitalized for more than 72 hours against his will."