One of my favorite content creators, Habitual Linecrosser, calls Poland "little European Texas," and not entirely without cause. While much of Europe seems interested in going down in a death spiral, Poland is not just arming itself to protect from Russian aggression, but they're not playing around with their border, either. Poland might not survive whatever's coming for the continent, but they're damn sure not going down without a fight.
Unfortunately for Poland, they experienced a mass shooting recently.
We know how this goes throughout most of Europe. The only possible reaction is gun control.
Yet Poland isn't like most of Europe. The question is, how different?
A legal analysis looked at some of the points up for discussion in the wake of the attack.
Now let us turn to an assessment of the measures under consideration
The first of these – tightening controls on the circulation of firearms – seems the most justified, as it addresses the weakest link. Five-year medical and psychological examinations should be extended to hunters, sport shooters, and holders of permits for training purposes, as provided for in the bill submitted to the Sejm (Print No. 1931). Monitoring under Article 6(2) of Directive 2021/555 (which allows for both continuous and periodic monitoring) should, in my view, be made continuous, with information sharing between the police, healthcare institutions, and special services, following the German model.
For semi-automatic long-barreled firearms capable of firing more than 11 rounds without reloading (lit. “b” of paragraph 7 of Category A of Annex I to the Directive), the conditions of Article 9(6) should be consistently applied, and such permits should be reviewed at least once every five years (Article 9(7)). It is worth considering the possibility of limiting police discretion regarding the number of firearms specified in a permit, as noted by K. Chałupka [40].
Now, I'm not exactly in agreement with the author of this piece, as this being the most justified, nor that it addresses the supposed weakest link. The problem here isn't that the psychological examinations didn't catch the killer; it's that they couldn't catch the killer before he became one.
These people aren't crazy, at least as it's broadly understood by the psychology establishment. In fact, most mass killers suffer from relatively minor mental illnesses, if any, rather than something profound.
Is Poland going to look at mild anxiety or depression as disqualifying conditions? If so, then remarkably few people will actually qualify, because everyone has a little depression now and then, even if it's a reaction to something like the death of a loved one or the loss of a job.
It's clear the author wants to change the laws to make this happen, which is why I find this next bit interesting:
Broader Rights for Citizens to Armed Self-Defense
The argument that an armed citizen can stop an attacker before the police arrive should not be dismissed. However, Directive 2021/555 permits the possession of firearms only if there is a lawful basis and provided that the person does not pose a danger to themselves, others, public order, or public safety (Article 6(1)).
Polish law requires a “stałe, realne i ponadprzeciętne zagrożenie” – that is, a constant, real, and extraordinary threat – for a permit for personal protection (Article 10, Section 3, Paragraph 1 of the Law on Weapons and Ammunition), and the courts interpret this requirement narrowly [50].
The right to necessary self-defense is already guaranteed by the Polish Criminal Code, and exceeding its limits under the influence of fear or agitation justified by the circumstances of the attack is not punishable (Sections 1 and 3 of Article 25). The dispute, therefore, centers on access to weapons. Moreover, the Kraków attacker himself possessed a legal firearm, and armed civilians in the crowd would have made it more difficult for the police to identify the shooter. Without convincing empirical data, I see no grounds for liberalization.
You know, American anti-gunners like to make this claim all the time, and I won't say it doesn't happen. However, there are times when police officers make it difficult for other officers to identify the shooter.
Plus, frankly, as we've seen in numerous cases here in the United States, a good guy with a gun is on the scene many times before the police can even start to respond. That's the point.
But the author says, "Without convincing empirical data, I see no grounds for liberalization." I'd like to point out that there's no convincing empirical data that most extensive psychological and medical screenings would have found this individual and denied him a permit in the first place.
What's interesting, though, isn't the casual dismissal of the argument, but that there is, in fact, an argument being made about gun rights in Poland.
This isn't something we see in other countries. We didn't see the response to the Paris terrorist attacks include even a rudimentary discussion of armed citizens meeting the threat. We didn't see it in Germany after multiple mass shootings, nor in anywhere else in Europe. We typically see this discussion take place in the United States.
And, apparently, in Poland, where there's enough behind it to warrant the media supposedly analyzing it.
May little European Texas become more like the United States in regard to gun rights for law-abiding citizens.