Earlier today, I wrote about the importance of using lawsuits to win battles we can't necessarily win in the legislature. We should still fight those battles, obviously, but then we turn to the courts should those efforts turn out to be fruitless. I don't think I was exactly breaking new ground there, either. I think most of us feel that way. It's why groups like the NRA, GOA, and SAF, among others, all have robust legal teams.
But sometimes, particularly with local ordinances, putting in the fight can yield a win without anyone ever darkening a courtroom's doorway.
That's the takeaway I got from this piece at Ammoland about the city of Winchester, Virginia.
Winchester has been here before. On February 9, 2021, City Council voted 7-2 along party lines to ban guns and ammunition in city government buildings, in city parks and at permitted events such as the Shenandoah Apple Blossom Festival. Council’s only two Republicans, Les Veach and Corey Sullivan, voted no. Of the 18 residents who spoke that night, all but one opposed the ban. The city relied on a Virginia law, effective July 1, 2020, that authorized localities to prohibit firearms in buildings and on property they own or use for governmental purposes.
...
The ban did not hold. Local residents, businesses, and national gun rights groups sued in Winchester Circuit Court in April 2021. After a September 2022 ruling, City Attorney Melisa Michelsen proposed removing the bans on guns in parks and at city-permitted events. The rewritten ordinance itself states that “a Virginia court has interpreted certain portions of the City Code” to “not be grounded in historic tradition.” Council approved the rewrite 7-2 in November 2022, again with Veach and Sullivan opposed, and kept the ban on city buildings. That building ban is the provision the parking garage lawsuit challenged, and the city carved the garages out of it in May 2026. That makes two court fights and two retreats, and the legal payments on the second one alone top $37,000.
Now, for state and local governments, $37,000 is a trivial amount. However, as writer John Crump notes, when you look at what attorneys charge, it's pretty clear that depending on the hourly rate for the attorneys, you're only looking at a handful of weeks of man-hours, all well before you ever get to the point of arguing before a judge.
Winchester has a population of about 28,000, and while this is Northern Virginia with its largely progressive outlook, the truth is that there's only so much taxpayer money to go around.
They ran headlong into a fight they couldn't afford to keep up indefinitely, especially since this case was likely to go a whole lot farther than the nearest judge. Dropping $37,000 before the fight even got that far along may well have been all the catalyst needed to pressure Winchester to change its mind on these measures.
I noted yesterday that it's been said that all politics is local, and there's something to that.
It means that no matter what a state or local government, or the feds, we need to dig in and fight, because the best win is the one that never goes to court. I don't care that they still don't respect gun rights. I care that they're forced to at least act like it.