As we reported last week, the Ohio legislature has sent a bill to Gov. Mike DeWine that allows for residents to purchase and possess short-barreled firearms and suppressors without first having to pay a federal tax and register those items under the NFA. The current law posed a barrier to possessing those items without going through the NFA process, even though the DOJ has said it will not enforce the registration requirement after a federal court declared that Congress didn't have the authority to impose it after it zeroed out the making and transfer taxes on those items.
These items are already legal to own in Ohio, but at least one sheriff in the Buckeye State is opposed to the legislature's recent move, claiming it will make the state a more dangerous place.
Hamilton County Sheriff Charmaine McGuffey said suppressors could make it harder for ShotSpotter, a gunshot detection system, to detect gunshots if a bill awaiting Gov. Mike DeWine’s signature becomes law.
“It’s going to be challenging for ShotSpotters to hear these muffled gunshots,” McGuffey said.
... McGuffey said she likely would not have opposed a bill focused only on suppressors if it included guidelines. She said the changes create “a pretty prolific black market.”
“You and I know, common sense, the wrong people get their hands on things that they’re not supposed to,” McGuffey said.
Suppressors aren't that difficult to make, so there's nothing preventing a prolific black market in those items right now. McGuffey doesn't appear to believe that's the case, so why exactly does she think that making it a little easier for people to lawfully own these items is suddenly going to increase criminal demand for suppressors?
Sheriff McGuffey is opposing legislation designed to prevent otherwise law-abiding Ohioans from facing state felony charges for possessing firearms and accessories that the federal government no longer requires them to register. Why? Because she believes that suppressors might make it harder for ShotSpotter to be effective.
Even if ShotSpotter doesn't reliably detect suppressed gunshots, that's no reason to make it harder for Ohioans to lawfully own a suppressor. And frankly, ShotSpotter isn't always great at detecting unsurpressed gunshots either.
An analysis of public data by the Weekly and Type Investigations indicates that ShotSpotter did not alert Chicago police to more than 20% of the shootings and reckless firearm discharges that occurred within its coverage area between January 2023 and August 2024, however, which raises questions about how well the company fulfilled its contractual obligations. That includes at least 180 gun homicides, as well as more than 600 nonfatal shootings and more than 400 reckless firearm discharges that ShotSpotter apparently failed to alert police to.
As Rep. Jean Schmidt told FOX19, "You can't limit somebody's right to own a weapon simply because you have a tool that can't respond to every kind of shot that is fired, silent or not."
That's exactly right.
Schmidt also defended suppressors as a means of protecting shooters' hearing, particularly when hunting or shooting clays. McGuffey's response? People have hunted without suppressors for centuries.
Well, people have also worked in factories without hearing protection for centuries. That doesn't mean hearing damage is something we should shrug off today.
McGuffey also questioned why anyone would need a short-barreled shotgun, suggesting that its only real purpose is to destroy or obliterate something. But Ohioans aren't required to convince their sheriff or any other member of law enforcement that they have a good enough reason to own a particular firearm, and they shouldn't have to.
The legislature has already made its decision. Lawmakers recognized that Ohio's existing restrictions could turn otherwise lawful conduct into a state felony, and they voted to fix that problem.
McGuffey hasn't demonstrated that SB 214 would unleash a wave of criminals armed with suppressors and short-barreled shotguns. She's offered speculation about a black market, concerns about ShotSpotter, and her personal doubts about why anyone needs these items.
Those aren't compelling reasons for Gov. Mike DeWine to veto the bill. The governor should sign SB 214 and let Ohioans exercise their rights without having to worry about running afoul of an unnecessary state restriction.
Editor’s Note: President Trump and Republicans across the country are doing everything they can to protect our Second Amendment rights and right to self-defense.
Help us continue to report on their efforts and legislative successes. Join Bearing Arms VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
Join the Conversation
VIP members get the ability to comment on articles.