Real-Life GTA Mission Goes Sideways for Armed California 'Squatter Removers'

Nov 19, 2026 5:31 PM
Premium
Advertisement
Real-Life GTA Mission Goes Sideways for Armed California 'Squatter Removers'
Graphic: Business Wire
VIP

With all the hype surrounding the release of Grand Theft Auto VI, it's easy to forget that you don't actually need a PlayStation 5 to experience the thrill of an armed raid gone horribly wrong. Apparently, all you need is a homeowner with a squatter problem and a guy who promises to make that problem disappear.

That's basically the premise of a bizarre real-life crime story out of San Bruno, California, where a group of black-clad men allegedly showed up at a home in the middle of the night armed with guns, a battering ram, and even a samurai sword intent on removing an unwanted occupant.

Unfortunately for the would-be eviction squad, California law doesn't recognize the Grand Theft Auto defense, and what might have made for a thrilling video game mission has instead resulted in some very real felony charges.

The whole episode sounds ridiculous, but underneath the absurdity there are serious questions about property rights, California's painfully slow eviction process, the Castle Doctrine, and what happens when people decide they're tired of waiting for the legal system to do its job.

The man behind the attempted eviction apparently believes California's Castle Doctrine gave him a legal basis for bringing armed men into the home. But the Castle Doctrine is meant to protect people against unlawful intruders, not give property owners a license to forcibly evict unwanted occupants. In fact, the people he was trying to remove may have had a stronger claim to its protections than the men he hired to get rid of them.

As the San Francisco Chronicle details, James Jacobs, who runs an outfit called ASAP Squatter Removal, is accused of some pretty serious crimes after being hired to oust a man who refused to exit his family home for months after it had been sold. Jacobs was tasked with getting Silvino Manzano Jr. to remove himself from the San Bruno home, which he had repeatedly refused to do once the new owner took possession of the property. 

For the job, Jacobs would use a tactic he described as “squatting on the squatters,” a police officer later testified. He hired Arthur Gutierrez, a 40-year-old veteran living in the South Bay, to move into the home under a lease contract Tran drafted, a police report shows. Gutierrez later told police he was planning to stay in the home for a month to keep others out. 

He did not respond to the Chronicle’s request for comment. 

Gutierrez told police that Jacobs told him to familiarize himself with California’s “castle doctrine,” which provides protections to people who use force to defend themselves against someone who invades their home if they have a “reasonable fear of imminent peril of death.”

Jacobs told Oaklandside the doctrine allowed him to enter a property with a new tenant and defend the tenant if squatters tried to intimidate or assault them. Without it, he said, he’d be out of business. 

But Courtney Burris, who spent 12 years as a prosecutor in San Francisco and Alameda County, said she believed Jacobs’ theory “doesn’t fit under the castle doctrine,” and would not survive scrutiny at trial. 

“You can’t start a fight and then have someone engage back, and then you come back and claim that they should be criminally or civilly liable for it,” she said. 

Here's what makes Jacobs' strategy so bizarre. California Penal Code Section 198.5 creates a presumption that a resident reasonably fears death or great bodily injury when someone unlawfully and forcibly enters their home, provided certain other conditions are met.

Now consider the situation from Manzano's perspective. He's inside the house where he's been living when a group of men allegedly forces its way in during the middle of the night. Even though Manzano no longer owned the property and was refusing to leave, that doesn't necessarily strip him of every legal protection against an unlawful, forcible entry.

I'm not suggesting Manzano would automatically have been justified in shooting anyone. But Jacobs' plan could easily have created a confrontation where the people he was trying to evict might have had a legitimate self-defense claim. That's a big risk to take over a property dispute.

As it turns out, though, Jacobs decided that it was unnecessary for Gutierrez to attempt to live in the home. 

Instead, the new owner told Manzano to pack his stuff and vacate the premises. When he refused to do so, Jacobs and his team went to work. 

Jacobs laid out the game plan as his camera recorded, the hilt of his sword poking into the frame.

They’d burst through the gate in two teams, Alpha and Bravo — each led by a “gunner.” Bravo team would advance through the garage, Alpha through a sliding patio door. Then they would meet in the middle, catching the squatters off-guard, Jacobs said. Once inside, they’d announce themselves as the new tenants.

“We’re gonna get in no matter what,” he said. “We gotta break in, we’re breaking in.” 

The team should expect a physical altercation, he said. If anyone saw an occupant with weapons, they were to shout “Warrior,” the code word to break out their swords.

Jacobs and his team did gain entry to the home, but Manzano and the friends he had staying with him didn't put up any physical resistance. Manzano chose instead to call 911. 

Jacobs was congratulating his team when Gutierrez reminded him they were armed and that police officers were on their way. “Listen, listen, listen,” Jacobs said. “We all need to hide some s—, OK?”

They stowed their weapons in the back of their cars. In a declaration later filed in court, Jacobs said this was standard practice for him so as not to alarm officers, and admitted “hide” was “a bad choice of words.” 

When the cops arrived, they detained six people, according to a report prepared by San Bruno police Corporal Anthony McKenna. They found one sword in the van, but didn’t recover any guns, leading them to question whether Manzano Jr., who described the men as armed, could have mistaken drills they had for handguns. 

There are so many more details here that you should really read the Chronicle story, but the short version is that Jacobs is now facing several felony charges, at last report Manzano is still squatting in the home, and the rightful owner Jerry Tran is being dinged for the run-down nature of the property that he owns but can't reside in (at least not without some unwanted roommates). 

To me, Tran is the most sympathetic individual in this crazy story. California's eviction process is Kafka-esque, particularly when a property owner is stuck paying for a house he can't actually use. Still, hiring a private army to kick down the door probably isn't the best way to get rid of a squatter. 

California's Castle Doctrine isn't a license to play SWAT team on someone's front porch. The law creates a presumption that a resident reasonably fears death or great bodily injury when someone unlawfully and forcibly enters their home, provided certain other conditions are met. It doesn't say that whoever holds the deed gets to send an armed squad into an occupied house and call it self-defense.

California makes it hard enough for law-abiding citizens to carry a gun for self-defense, and its eviction laws can make it even harder for property owners to reclaim their own homes. I can understand why someone in Tran's position might be tempted to take matters into his own hands. But there's a big difference between protecting your property and hiring an armed crew to storm an occupied house.

That might work in Vice City. In San Bruno, it's a good way to trade a squatter problem for a criminal case.

Comments

Recommended

Trending on Bearing Arms Videos