From Newton, Massachusetts to Goleta, California, a number of communities have put zoning laws in place in recent years that restrict where gun stores can operate. These restrictions often shunt prospective gun stores to industrial areas or out-of-the-way locations far from other retailers, but they generally at least theoretically allow for an FFL to open its doors.
The Common Council in Summit, New Jersey, on the other hand, is aiming at completely banning firearm retailers from the community. There are currently no gun shops in Summit, and a majority of the council wants to keep it that way. On a 5-1 vote this week, the council voted to advance an ordinance that supporters claim would ensure the town remains a "gun store-free zone."
Councilman Dan Crisafulli said the ordinance would explicitly prohibit firearms shops under Summit’s development regulations, reducing ambiguity in the code.
“It does not have an impact on our right to bear arms or own arms,” Crisafulli said. “We currently have no firearms shops in Summit, but our ability to protect our town against this land use is not assured.”
“Firearm shops are a unique form of land use and development which have been demonstrated to pose significant challenges to neighborhood character, public safety, security, and theft,” Crisafulli said.
The proposal would prohibit firearms shops in every zoning district, covering establishments that sell, rent, deal in or transfer firearms. Businesses selling only accessories, such as scopes, lights and mounts, would be excluded.
If adopted, the measure would add firearms shops to two other categories of land use Council moved to prohibit this year: detention facilities and AI data centers. Council approved those bans in June.
The Supreme Court has given municipalities considerable leeway in passing zoning regulations on businesses with First Amendment activities, like adult bookstores. But in City of Los Angeles v. Alameda Books, Justice Anthony Kennedy suggested that a city "may not regulate the secondary effects of speech by suppressing the speech itself."
Kennedy's statement came in a concurring opinion, not a majority opinion, and its not directly applicable to a potential Second Amendment challenge if Summit does adopt its ban on gun stores. But it should still give the Common Council pause. Calling something a zoning regulation doesn't place it beyond constitutional review, and based on existing Third Circuit precedent, a prohibition on gun shops appears to implicate the plain text of the Second Amendment. The appellate court has said that a "categorical exception for rules 'prohibiting the commercial sale of firearms' would be 'untenable in light of Heller," and that's exactly what Summit is trying to do.
Under Bruen, Summit would likely face the burden of demonstrating that the gun store ban is consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearms regulation. I've found historical examples of municipalities regulating gunpowder storage, firearm sales, and the locations of certain firearms-related activities, but no comparable tradition of towns categorically prohibiting gun stores from operating inside city limits.
Councilman Andrew Smith, an attorney and the lone vote against the proposal, counseled his colleagues that they're inviting a lawsuit if they proceed with the gun store ban.
“I’ve studied the law on this and I think that a total ban on something that could be certainly construed by the current Supreme Court as having a total restriction on arms could be a violation of the Second Amendment,” he said.
Such a challenge, Smith said, “could cost the city significant time, money, and resources to address.”
Residents will have the opportunity to weigh in on the potential gun store ban at the Common Council's December 1 meeting. Perhaps the public can talk some sense into a majority of the council members. If not, the courts will have to do so, and the gun store ban could end up being a very expensive experiment in just how far a community can go in restricting a fundamental civil right.
Editor’s Note: The radical Left will stop at nothing to enact their extreme gun control agenda and strip us of our Second Amendment rights.
Help us continue to report on and expose the Democrats’ gun-grabbing schemes. Join Bearing Arms VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
Join the Conversation
VIP members get the ability to comment on articles.