New Hampshire isn't like a lot of New England states. They're the Live Free or Die state, after all, and they tend to mean it. It's a libertarian state in the midst of profound progressivism. However, no state is perfect, and that includes the only New England state I'd consider moving to. They have their challenges.
But for one man, the challenge is federal, and it involves trying to buy a gun in New Hampshire but being blocked by a couple of charges from Massachusetts.
So far, nothing unusual. We see this happen fairly regularly. Felonies follow you, after all.
Only the charges weren't felonies. They were DUIs.
The man in question challenged the law, which didn't work out well, but his case has new life thanks to the First Circuit.
A federal appeals court on Friday, Nov. 13, revived a New Hampshire man’s Second Amendment challenge to the federal ban that stopped him from buying a gun over two old Massachusetts DUIs. The First Circuit threw out the dismissal of Marshall v. Blanche and sent the case back to the District of New Hampshire for a fresh look under the Supreme Court’s Bruen test.
Thomas Marshall was convicted of DUI in Massachusetts in 1997 and again in 2005. The offense carries up to two and a half years behind bars. That is the problem. 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1) bars gun possession by anyone convicted of a crime punishable by more than a year. The exemption for state misdemeanors only covers those punishable by two years or less.
This, of course, is the problem. This essentially makess it the equivalent of a felony, even if it's not.
It's still just a couple of DUIs, but the punishment is sufficient to trigger the federal prohibition, which is dumb.
Marshall moved to New Hampshire in 2023 and tried to buy a gun. New Hampshire State Police told him the FBI had denied him, listing the DUIs as federal disqualifiers. He says he wants a handgun and a long gun for self-defense at home and has not tried again for fear of prosecution.
A federal judge dismissed his suit in June 2025. The judge relied on United States v. Torres-Rosario, a 2011 First Circuit case that largely shut down as-applied challenges to § 922(g)(1), meaning challenges arguing the law is unconstitutional as used against one specific person. The judge called Marshall’s “repeated drunk driving” “ongoing reckless conduct.”
I'm not sure that two DUIs nearly a decade apart is "ongoing reckless conduct," especially since there doesn't seem to have been a repeat in the last 20 years.
I'm not going to excuse drunk driving. I know that with a blood alcohol threshold of 0.08, a lot of people might think they're fine to drive because they're not drunk, but they're still too far to be legally safe. There's nothing wrong with telling people to take the hit and learn from their mistakes.
But DUI is not the kind of crime that can or should come with a lifetime prohibition for gun ownership. It's just not.
It's a glorified traffic violation, for crying out loud.
Unfortunately for Marshall, this win only goes so far. He's still got charges for criminal possession of a firearm, and that is going to stand as the First Circuit ruled he lacks standing to challenge that side of it — primarily because the court doesn't seem to believe he's suffered the kind of damage a court could fix — but he can challenge the NICS denial.
No, that doesn't make a lot of sense to me, either, but there we go.
The truth of the matter is that the judge shouldn't have dismissed the suit, and now it goes back to the district court, where it will be heard. In time, it might end up before the Supreme Court, and that would be beyond ridiculous.
For a couple of DUIs.