We're just a little more than two weeks away from oral arguments in the Supreme Court case that will determine whether "assault weapon" bans can survive a Second Amendment challenge, and the top prosecutor in Cook County, Illinois is still trying to weasel out of the litigation challenging the county's semi-auto ban.
Cook County State's Attorney Eileen O'Neill Burke filed a brief with the Court earlier this month arguing that if the justices accept a request by Cutberto Viramontes to drop out of the lawsuit bearing his name, the entire litigation against the Cook County gun ban falls apart. Burke contends that Christopher Khaya, the other named plaintiff, has declared he wants to purchase an IMI Galil for self-defense, and since that the rifle is based on the AK-47 platform and not the AR-15 platform that he doesn't have standing, nor does Second Amendment Foundation and Firearms Policy Coalition as organizational plaintiffs.
SAF and FPC responded to Burke's brief with one of their own, pointing out that the IMI Galil is still covered by Cook County's gun ban, and that other members of the organizations would possess AR-15s in the county were it not for the ordinance. Now Burke has replied to that reply, doubling down on her assertions that without Mr. Viramontes himself, the Cook County lawsuit is moot.
According to Burke, it "makes no difference to this analysis that Khaya’s IMI Galil weapon is also prohibited by Cook County’s ordinance," because she contends that the Supreme Court "did not grant review of the ordinance’s facial validity."
The question that will be answered by SCOTUS is whether "the Second and Fourteenth Amendments guarantee the right to possess AR-15 platform and similar semiautomatic rifles." That question was actually posed by the plaintiffs' attorneys in Viramontes, and it makes no sense for them to have presented a question that wouldn't cover all of their clients. Cook County thinks the IMI Galil is similar enough to an AR-15 that they're both considered "assault weapons," but now Burke wants the Court to consider the question so narrowly that the county's gun ban could still survive in some fashion even if the justices rule that AR-15s and other "similar" arms cannot be banned.
Burke also takes issue with new declarations by Khaya and FPC/SAF member Ed Smolen about wanting to possess AR-15s, which she says "smacks of 'gamesmanship, as does their decision to seek Viramontes’ dismissal after Cook County filed ts responsive brief in this case."
I think Burke is projecting here. It's her office that's actually engaging in gamesmanship by trying to wriggle out of the Supreme Court's review of Cook County's ordinance with her specious argument.
Let's not forget that Burke's office has already spent years defending a law that prohibits ordinary citizens from possessing some of the most popular rifles in the country. Now, with the Supreme Court finally poised to decide whether those bans violate the Second Amendment, Cook County suddenly wants to get very particular about which rifles are similar to which other rifles.
Funny how that works.
There's another problem with Burke's argument, and it comes courtesy of her own office. In Cook County's merits brief, filed just last month, prosecutors listed several firearms prohibited by the ordinance, including the AK-47 and AR-15, and then collectively referred to them as "AR-15 platform weapons."
The Ordinance is limited to “assault weapons”that are strictly defined as “semiautomatic rifle[s]” able to accept a detachable large capacity magazine and one or more of certain military-style features, such as a folding or telescoping stock, a pistol grip without a stock, a barrel shroud, or a muzzle brake. The Ordinance makes it unlawful to“manufacture, sell, offer or display for sale, give, lend, transfer ownership of, acquire, carry or possess any assault weapon.” Specific firearms are outlawed under the Ordinance, including the “AK-47,” “AR-15,” “Bushmaster XM15,” “Bushmaster Carbon15,” “Bushmaster MOE series,” “ArmaLite M15,” “Armalite M15-T,” and “Olympic Arms PCR.” Id. § 54-211(7) (hereafter AR-15 platform weapons).
That's right. When Cook County was defending its ban, an AK-47 was close enough to an AR-15 to be lumped into the same category. Now that the county is trying to get its case tossed out, SCOTUS is supposed to believe that an AK-based Galil is so different from an AR-15 that Khaya can't challenge the ban.
Apparently, the similarities between these rifles depend on whether Cook County is trying to ban them or defend its ban in court.
There's a legitimate legal question about whether the justices should consider the new declarations from Khaya and Smolen. Burke argues that those statements should have been part of the record in the lower courts, and that her office hasn't had an opportunity to question either man about his claims. The justices may well take that objection seriously.
But even if they disregard those declarations, there's still the matter of Khaya's Galil. Cook County has prohibited him from possessing it, and he's challenging the constitutionality of that prohibition. The county's position essentially boils down to arguing that his rifle is close enough to an AR-15 to ban, but not close enough to keep the lawsuit alive.
I would be shocked if the justices will buy Burke's argument, but even if they do dismiss Viramontes they're still going to address the constitutionality of semiautomatic rifle bans through the companion case out of Connecticut, Grant v. Higgins. So even a victory for Cook County on this procedural question wouldn't necessarily spare its ordinance from the consequences of a Supreme Court ruling.
Burke can argue about the differences between an AR-15 and an AK-47 all she wants (at least when she's not touting their similarities). The bigger questions are why Cook County believes it can prohibit peaceable residents from owning either one, and why she apparently believes a majority of the justices won't notice when her office changes its tune about which guns are similar depending on which argument it's trying to make.