There have been a lot of people who try to make the case that so-called gun violence has further repercussions than just the act itself. I've seen many that tried to link proximity to shootings as somehow relevant to various things. I have, generally, ripped those studies apart. After all, when your range is a mile, and you're looking at high-crime neighborhoods, you're going to find all sorts of things that simply co-exist in these areas independently.
However, we can't dismiss the possibility of being in such proximity creating issues for the people stuck in these communities.
Well, we couldn't.
A new study seems to suggest that there's no psychological distress associated with it.
Key PointsQuestion Is neighborhood exposure to firearm violence associated with psychosocial distress, perceptions of safety, and substance use among adults in California?
Findings In this cross-sectional study of 45 916 adults, 17.2% experienced a shooting within 500 m of their home. Shooting exposure was associated with worry about experiencing firearm violence, feeling unsafe in one’s neighborhood, and substance use but not psychological distress overall.
Meaning Neighborhood firearm violence may affect residents beyond direct physical injury by influencing perceived safety and negative coping behaviors, but longitudinal research is needed to establish causality.
Of course, in the abstract, they do try to make the case of these incidents leading to substance abuse, but again, is that a matter of the shootings leading to substance abuse, or is there simply a comorbidity of substance abuse and so-called gun violence?
The problem with this research, though, is that it was all done via survey. People will often try to tell researchers what they want to hear, at least to a point, so that any psychological distress might be downplayed while any links between unsavory behavior and the violence get played up.
I mean, let's keep in mind that 500 meters is nearly five and a half football fields away. That's not super far away, but it's also not right in front of someone's face, either. The differences between witnessing a shooting and being near one are very different. I've been even closer than that to two different incidents over the years, and my own experience is that any of those feelings are present but fleeting.
And despite my bourbon collection, I don't have a substance abuse issue.
Yet I'll grant that I also don't suffer from any psychological distress as a result of these incidents. They happened, things settled down, and while I maintain a degree of vigilance, to say nothing of a profound desire to move, I'm not overly freaked out about anything.
Personally, I think the researchers made a connection that wasn't there with things like substance abuse, but only because they couldn't make the link to psychological distress they wanted. I will give them credit for using a decent sample size, though. Nearly 46,000 people is a solid sample, even if there are issues with surveys for this kind of research.
At the end of the day, so-called gun violence will remain an issue, but it's not causing the problems many people want it to cause.
Which is fine. Can't people being shot be enough of a problem on its own?
Editor’s Note: President Trump and Republicans across the country are doing everything they can to protect our Second Amendment rights and right to self-defense.
Help us continue to report on their efforts and legislative successes. Join Bearing Arms VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
Join the Conversation
VIP members get the ability to comment on articles.