The ATF has made a lot of positive headway under the leadership of Director Robert Cekada. Unfortunately, while he's a good egg at the top of the pyramid, there are still plenty of bad ones at most of the levels below him. You don't just change a culture overnight, no matter how good a director you actually are, and you definitely don't undo decades of hostility toward lawful gun owners and dealers with the stroke of a pen.
So it's unsurprising that while some positive moves have been made, some of them aren't as positive as we might like to believe.
That became very obvious following a recent House Oversight Committee hearing on the ATF's storage of records.
In particular, a rule change that would take the indefinite retention of records that started under President Joe Biden's administration, though who knows who actually gave the order.
The ATF is now either returning to the 20-year standard, which was the norm for decades, or to 30 years. Either is better than an indefinite retention period, which turns records into a de facto registration scheme.
Even with a shorter retention period, those concerns don't completely disappear.
ATF claims its proposed records retention rule helps law enforcement, but it could have significant implications for Americans’ privacy and Second Amendment rights.
- ATF’s proposed rule would cap out-of-business records retention at 20 or 30 years. However, the two retention periods effectively stack: a record could sit with a dealer for 30 years, then with ATF for another 30, meaning the personal information and firearm purchase history of a law-abiding American could remain in government hands for up to 60 years.
Now, think about the average life expectancy for a moment. Someone who buys a rifle on the first day a store is open, which happens to be the customer's 18th birthday, could well die of old age while his records are still technically active. How is that remotely sane?
Retired ATF Assistant Director Wally Nelson testified, "ATF’s own data that they wrote up in the [Notice of Proposed Rulemaking] for this proposed change indicated that the number of traces coming on records that are over 20 years old has been reduced quite a bit in the last 15 years." In other words, there's not a lot of reason to even hold onto records beyond 20 years. The idea of holding onto them for 60 years is absolutely insane, all things considered.
Oh, and when I said the current system was already a de facto gun registration scheme, I wasn't just making stuff up.
Subcommittee Chairman Clay Higgins (R-La.) exposed how current ATF record retention practices creates a database that is searchable by name.
Subcommittee Chairman Higgins: “So these records are continuously coming into ATF. It’s a hell of a lot of manpower and energy being invested to add to the already existing 1.4 billion digital records that we have on file. And is it true, Mr. Nelson? Mr. Johnston? Mr. Chiaffulo… is it true that with very easy IT adjustment, this record compilation will be searchable by name. Is that true, Mr. Johnston?”Mr. Johnston: “Yes. This this weekend I wrote a program using––“
Subcommittee Chairman Higgins: “Is that true, Mr. Nelson?”
Mr. Nelson: “It could be, I don’t know. I’m not a computer expert.”
Mr. Chiaffulo: “ChatGPT gave me directions on how to get here today, Mr. Chairman. So I think anything’s possible.”
I'm not an IT expert myself, but I do know that most databases can be searched by any information that's within the database. Even if the interface people use only allows, say, a serial number and manufacturer, that doesn't mean that the interface can't be modified to look for people's names.
That's a problem, because federal law prohibits any federal gun database, yet the ATF has essentially built one as it is, even if it's an inefficient one.
What needs to happen is that any records older than a certain age need to be destroyed, either by the store after that threshold is met or by the ATF should an FFL go out of business. If the ATF gets a record tomorrow from November 22, 2006, it should be set aside to be destroyed in a couple of days. That's about the minimum that should be accepted.
And we're putting up with a whole lot more.