Despite the setbacks in the midterms, we're still living in a relatively golden age for gun rights. While some states are looking at new restrictions, if they can manage to get them, the federal landscape is very different. We can get suppressors and short-barreled long guns without ATF permission, at least in most states. That's massive.
But is it really the win we like to think it is?
Not really, as Tennessee Gun Owners notes in their call to sign a petition:
Here’s what that means in practice. Since October 9, ATF hasn’t required prior approval or registration to make or transfer a suppressor, a short barreled rifle, a short barreled shotgun or an AOW, and ATF says that applies to everyone, not just the people who sued. The federal tax on them has been $0 since January 1. That’s a real win for Tennessee gun owners.
But look at how it’s built. The court order itself only protects the plaintiffs and their members and customers, and Tennessee isn’t one of the states that sued. Everything beyond that rests on ATF’s own enforcement policy, and a policy can be reversed by the next director or the next administration with another letter.
Only Congress can lock this in. Right now the bills that would do it are still sitting in committee, with no markup and no vote, and every one of them dies when the new Congress convenes on January 3.
They're absolutely correct.
Right now, we're fine. If you're in a state that permits NFA items but doesn't explicitly require ATF registration, you're fine at least for the next two years, maybe longer. If you're in a state that requires the registration, then you're going to be fine for even longer.
But as soon as Democrats take the White House, if these changes aren't locked in place by Congress, the new ATF director will, possibly as his or her first act, be to dismantle as many gains as possible. If the ATF giveth, the ATF can taketh away.
For it to last, we need Congress to get off its keister and get something done.
[Editor's note: things could change even sooner if the next Congress manages to reimpose the making and transfer taxes on NFA items. The removal of those taxes is what led to the court order, and the reimposition of those taxes could lead to the current injunction being lifted. — Cam]
I know, I know, asking politicians to get things done is like asking a fat guy to lay off the cake. They can do it in theory, but in practice, good luck.
Still, this is a lame duck Congress, with some of these current lawmakers on their way out. They might as well step up and get some things done. At least, get them done if they can't. It's not like Democrats are really so anti-filibuster they won't use it, but at least give us something that looks like effort on the way out the door.
As it stands, those gains on suppressors and short-barreled long guns are what they are, but what they are is temporary at best. I think we all want to see it become permanent, especially those of us stuck in states where NFA items have to be registered with the ATF. Take them off the NFA list and all is glorious in the world.
Editor’s Note: President Trump and Republicans across the country are doing everything they can to protect our Second Amendment rights and right to self-defense.
Help us continue to report on their efforts and legislative successes. Join Bearing Arms VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
Join the Conversation
VIP members get the ability to comment on articles.