A Supreme Court Domino Effect: The Gun Control Cases Waiting on Viramontes

Nov 20, 2026 4:01 PM
Premium
Advertisement
A Supreme Court Domino Effect: The Gun Control Cases Waiting on Viramontes
AP Photo/Susan Walsh
VIP

On December 2, the Supreme Court will hear oral arguments over the "assault weapon" bans in Cook County, Illinois and the state of Connecticut. A decision probably won't come down until next June, but when it does the Viramontes verdict is going to have a domino effect that could topple laws all around the country. 

As Firearms Policy Coalition noted on X today, there are almost a half-dozen cases that FPC is involved with in state and federal court that are officially on hold until SCOTUS decides on the constitutionality of banning commonly-owned semi-automatic rifles. 

There's one other FPC lawsuit not listed in the X post. FPC v. Davenport is a challenge to New Jersey's ban on short-barreled rifles, and on November 9 a federal judge granted a joint motion for a stay in the proceedings until the Viramontes case is resolved. 

Beyond the FPC cases, there are several other lawsuits that are also on hold. And they don't all deal with bans on "assault weapons."  

Schiller v. Bonta, for instance, is a challenge to California's ban on the sale, purchase, and/or possession of pepper projectile launchers. The case was stayed in district court back in early September. 

United States v. District of Columbia was stayed in August. That lawsuit challenges the ban on AR-15s and other so-called assault weapons in Washington, D.C., as well as the District's prohibition on suppressors. 

In addition to the cases that are on hold in the lower courts, the Supreme Court has also kept ahold of Duncan v. Bonta and Gator's Custom Guns v. Washington. Both lawsuits are challenges to bans on "high capacity" magazines, and it looks like SCOTUS is planning to grant cert, vacate the lower court decisions, and remand the cases back down to the Ninth Circuit for a do-over in light of what the justices say in Viramontes. 

The justices don't have to go the GVR route, but I can't see any good reason to keep those petitions pending unless the Court expects its decision in Viramontes to have a direct bearing on the constitutionality of magazine bans too. A GVR wouldn't automatically invalidate those laws either, but it would force the Ninth Circuit to reconsider its earlier decisions that those bans are hunky dory under whatever standard the Supreme Court establishes.

And it's not just gun rights groups waiting for that guidance. New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport has asked the Supreme Court to hold its petition in Davenport v. Association of New Jersey Rifle & Pistol Clubs, where the Third Circuit ruled against the state's ban on magazines holding more than ten rounds (and its ban on so-called assault weapons). New Jersey wants another opportunity to defend its restrictions, and the state is apparently hoping that Viramontes will give them the opportunity to do so. 

Meanwhile, other challenges to state and local gun bans are effectively frozen. In Bevis v. Naperville, a federal district judge has stayed proceedings involving Illinois' ban on commonly owned semi-automatic firearms and magazines. A federal judge has also stayed the Justice Department's lawsuit against Virginia's newly enacted gun restrictions. In New York, Lane v. James, a challenge to the state's prohibition on certain semi-automatic rifles, is on hold as well.

The number of cases awaiting a decision shows just how consequential Viramontes could be. The Supreme Court isn't simply deciding whether Cook County and Connecticut can prohibit possession of some of the most popular rifles in the country. Its reasoning could determine how lower courts evaluate bans on magazines, short-barreled rifles, suppressors, and even less-lethal defensive weapons.

A ruling that commonly owned semi-automatic rifles are protected arms that cannot be categorically banned would leave states defending similar prohibitions in a difficult position. It could also undermine the reasoning courts have used to uphold restrictions on other arms and accessories.

For years, gun owners have watched challenges to these bans move at a glacial pace through the courts, often with contradictory results. Now dozens of legal arguments could turn on a single Supreme Court opinion.

The December 2 arguments will last only a few hours. The consequences, though, are going to reverberate through Second Amendment litigation for years to come. 

Comments

Recommended

Trending on Bearing Arms Videos